We introduce a novel measure for the quantum property commonly known as $magic$ by considering the R\'enyi entropy of the probability distribution associated to a pure quantum state given by the square of the expectation value of Pauli strings in that state. We show that this is a good measure of magic from the point of view of resource theory and show bounds with other known measures of magic. The R\'enyi entropy of magic has the advantage of being easily computable because it does not need a minimization procedure. We define the magic power of a unitary operator as the average entropy of magic attainable by the action of this operator on the magic-free states, that is, stabilizer states, and show the basic properties of this quantity. As an application, we show that the magic power is intimately connected to out-of-time-order correlation functions and that maximal levels of magic are necessary for quantum chaos.

Main ideas

“stabilizer states” – states that are classically simulable

“magic” – the computational power of non-stabilizer states

Measures of magic

relative entropy of magic (computing an extreme over Pauli decompositions)

this paper: “Renyi entropy” – probability of a state represented by a Pauli string

Renyi entropy

Consider \(\langle \psi | P | \psi \rangle ^2\) that’s normalized to be a probability distribution.

Then define Renyi entropies (p log p)

faithful (0 iff a stabilizer state)

stability under free operations

additivity over tensor product

The 2-entropy is bounded by log(d).

The Renyi entropy is between the min-relative entropy and the stabilizer nullity.

the min-relative entropy is related to the maximum stabilizer overlap

the stabilizer nullity is the number of Paulis that don’t affect the state up to a sign.

The main benefit is that it’s computable for various n.

Magic Power

How much “magic” is produced by unitary evolution?

Let’s consider the magic of a unitary (the magic generated from an average stabilizer state)

The linear magic power is zero iff the unitary commutes with a matrix related to the projector onto \(S_4\).

Most unitaries are concentrated in magic power around log(d/4).

The magic power lower-bounds the t-count (with high probability, \(t(U) = \Omega(n)\).

This gives a way to characterize t-counts as “how much extraclassical computation” you are doing.
Three T gates are worth more than Toffoli gates.

Out-of-time-order correlation

We need order N gates to get 8-OTOC (related to quantum chaos). How much magic is needed to drive a quantum system towards chaos?

We can talk about a random Clifford circuit, “doped” by layers of non-clifford one-qubit gates. The magic power increases with the number of doping layers.

The Renyi entropy is directly related to the 2-OTOC functions.